What Happens If Egg Yolk Gets In Egg Whites For A Meringue?

I’ve always been under the impression, based on dire warnings from many sources, that even the tiniest speck of egg yolk will keep egg whites from beating to a stiff peak. But I wanted to see if that would really happen.

egg yolks in meringue

This article includes affiliate links that will pay a commission if they’re used to purchase something. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

egg yolk in egg whites

“Oh, it just won’t work if there’s any fat in the eggs”, we’ve all been told. 

This is beaten into the heads of every baker, and we all live in fear of getting yolks in the meringue.


I have wondered about this many times as I killed myself trying to get out a tiny speck of yolk that made its way into the egg whites before making meringue-based buttercreams. 

What would happen if I DIDN’T manage to get every speck out? 

I’m sure that it’s pretty much impossible to do, anyway, so what the heck, I decided to try it out.

(For an article about how to make citrus curd with egg yolks, click here.)

I made a batch of Italian meringue buttercream using the recipe from The Cake Bible (which, incidentally, also says that you have to get every bit of fat out of the egg whites.) 

I deliberately left a pretty good-sized blob of yolk in the whites, about the size of a pea. 

This wasn’t a lot, but it’s a lot more than I would have left in the whites if I ever had an egg break in the process of separating them.

After whipping it up, it looked perfectly fine, and unless I was hallucinating, it was holding a stiff peak.

italian meringue buttercream

Figuring that the horrible effect might happen after the butter was added, I went ahead and finished the icing. 

What would happen? Would it work? Would the buttercream break and be non-recoverable?


The butter went in fine, and I didn’t see any difference between it and other batches I’d made ever while sweating about a speck of yolk.

Now I can’t vouch for other things made with a meringue, and if you’re making something that needs to hold the shape it might be different. 

But for IMBC, this is proof that if you get a tiny bit of egg yolk in the whites it isn’t going to kill it. 

I don’t recommend adding half a yolk, but a pea-sized bit per batch apparently makes no difference at all.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top